A Frustrating Fitting (Dismay-me Gears are not the Cream of the crop)

A few days ago, I had a bash at one of the last major parts of the build: the gear system.

I’ve selected a Campag 7-speed setup, mainly because the were about the last of the downtube shifters before everything went onto the levers. However, despite looking mint, there are a series of problems.

  1. The left lever (front mech) went on fine and works – mostly – a treat. Pushing the lever forward unscrews the tightener though, which means next time I pull it back it doesn’t stick. I suspect this could be fixed with thread lock but I haven’t tested yet.
  2. The right lever (rear mech) has a litany of issues. Firstly, the indexing mechanism works by engaging a spring into a rotating ratchet to hold each gear. Fine, except the previous owner has glued the springs to make it permanently friction-based, not index-based. That’s annoying and it’s too late to return it.
  3. It turns out my bosses are slightly longer than required – or there’s a washer missing. Consequently the lever body moved laterally which meant there was no friction whatsoever which is rather important in a friction-based lever.

I eventually stopped it rattling by placing an M8 washer over the boss. It was a little small but nothing that a file couldn’t sort out. You can see it in the second picture. Unfortunately, this makes another metal-on-metal interface which gives twice the opportunity to slip; and slip it does!

Finally, when on the inner ring, the chain rubs against the outer ring in four out of seven gears.

I am quite annoyed and don’t know how to proceed. My current plan of attack for each side, and in ascending order of cost, is…

Left Hand Side (front mech):

  1. Use threadlock on the bolt and degrease the friction plates.

Right Hand Side (rear mech):

  1. Use acetone to dissolve whatever is holding the springs, returning it to index-based shifting.
  2. Use friction paste (like that used for seat posts) on the washer faces to see if that gives enough grip. Chance of success low and I’d still have no indexing but at least I already have all the parts.
  3. Assuming the LHS is working, buy a friction-based RH lever. These are fairly affordable, can match and, if I accept no indexing, would be fine.
  4. Buy another set of the same. Maybe there’s a part missing. Afterwards, compete in the Tokyo 2020 straw-clutching competition.
  5. Abort 7sp and find a set of 8sp levers and an 8sp cassette. I’d also need to find a guide that takes the cable around the bosses; these are readily available and as a bonus tend to have inline barrel adjusters to keep the tension right. This feels like compromising on the vision; however, is probably the better technical solution.

Chain Rub:

  • Buy an 8 speed chain. My current one is 6sp so is considerably wider than it needs to be. This should work with any of the options above.

Given received wisdom seems to be that Syncro / Syncro II were both abject failures, I’m leaning towards 3.3, which is a shame because those downtube levers look really good.